New York Gaming Commission Faces Conflict of Interest Concerns

Shorenstein, the daughter of veteran gambling lobbyist Stuart Shorenstein, was appointed despite her father’s active involvement in the industry.

The Shorenstein Family’s Gaming Connections

Stuart Shorenstein, a notable figure in the gambling lobbying sector, represents various clients including Evolution Malta, a firm pushing for the legalization of online betting in New York. Additionally, Cozen O’Connor, a firm co-founded by Stuart, is lobbying for a casino above Saks Fifth Avenue in Manhattan.

The appointment has been met with criticism from government watchdogs and industry experts. John Kaehny of Reinvent Albany expressed disbelief at the decision, questioning the appropriateness of appointing someone directly connected to the industry’s lobbying activities. State Senator Joseph Addabbo, chair of the Senate Committee on Racing, Gaming and Wagering, also acknowledged his interactions with Stuart on gaming issues.

Official Responses and Justifications

Despite the concerns, Lee Park, deputy executive director of the state Gaming Commission, defended Marissa Shorenstein’s appointment, citing her qualifications and ethical standards. The Gaming Commission also noted that Shorenstein had recused herself from cases involving her father’s firm.

This development raises broader questions about the governance and regulation of the gaming industry in New York. It highlights the delicate balance between industry interests and regulatory oversight, especially when personal connections intersect with official duties.

Our Comment on the Article

Governor Hochul’s appointment of Marissa Shorenstein to the New York Gaming Commission amidst her family’s deep ties to the gambling industry is a clear example of the intricate and often controversial relationship between politics and industry regulation.

While the Commission asserts that ethical procedures are in place to mitigate conflicts of interest, the perception of impartiality is crucial in maintaining public trust. As the gaming industry continues to evolve and expand, especially in key markets like New York, the integrity and transparency of regulatory bodies will remain under scrutiny. It is essential for regulators to not only act impartially but also be perceived as such, to ensure the industry’s fair and responsible growth.